Conn Smythe Trophy Odds: Mitch Marner vs. Frederik Andersen and Where the Value Lies
The Conn Smythe Trophy race has come down to two names at the top — but the best value in this market may not be where most bettors are looking.

The Conn Smythe Trophy race for the 2026 Stanley Cup Final is shaping up as a two-horse battle at the top, with a handful of compelling value options underneath. As Carolina and Vegas prepare to drop the puck, here is a breakdown of the odds and where the smart money might land.
The Top Two: Marner vs. Andersen
Mitch Marner enters the Final as the betting favorite at +175, and his postseason numbers make a compelling case. The Vegas forward leads every skater in the 2026 playoffs with 21 points — seven goals and 14 assists — and carries a plus-12 rating through 16 games. He has been the most impactful player on the ice at every stage of the postseason, and if the Golden Knights win the series, Marner is the near-certain Conn Smythe winner.
The argument against him is simple: goaltenders have a strong historical track record in the Conn Smythe voting. And Carolina’s Frederik Andersen has had arguably the most dominant postseason performance of any goalie in recent memory. Andersen is 12-1 with a 1.44 goals-against average and a .928 save percentage. His GAA is the lowest for any playoff goaltender at this stage since the 2012 Los Angeles Kings, and Carolina’s team goals-against average of 1.62 in the playoffs is also the best since that same Kings squad — which won the Cup. If Carolina wins, Andersen is almost certainly lifting the trophy.
The practical Conn Smythe calculus is this: the winner almost always comes from the Cup-winning team. Carolina is the -155 series favorite. That makes Andersen at +250 a stronger value than Marner at +175, because if you believe Carolina wins — as the majority of betting money does — Andersen is the more likely recipient at better odds.
The Best Value Pick: Taylor Hall
Taylor Hall at +700 is the most compelling value bet on the board. Hall leads Carolina with 16 points — five goals and 10 assists — in 13 postseason games, making him the team’s top offensive contributor among skaters. If Carolina wins the series and the narrative requires a skater rather than a goaltender to claim the award, Hall is the clear choice. The former Hart Trophy winner has been chasing this moment for years, and there is a strong case to be made that voters would reward a compelling personal story combined with strong production numbers.
The historical trend does lean toward goaltenders on championship teams receiving the Conn Smythe, but it is not absolute. In a series where Andersen is expected to be excellent but not necessarily spectacular in every game, a breakout offensive run from Hall could swing the vote. At +700, the price is generous.
Other Names Worth Knowing
Logan Stankoven of Carolina checks in at +900 with nine goals in the playoffs, making him one of the more dangerous offensive threats on either roster. If Carolina wins and Stankoven leads the team in goals during the Final, he would become a legitimate candidate — but he would need to have a dominant individual series to leapfrog Hall or Andersen in the voting.
Other Game Picks
On the Vegas side, Carter Hart at +2000 is intriguing as a deep longshot. He has posted a 12-4 record with a 2.22 GAA and .924 save percentage, and there is a precedent for goaltenders from the winning team receiving the Conn Smythe even when their numbers are not historically dominant. If Vegas pulls the upset and Hart stands on his head, that price would look very different in hindsight.
Jack Eichel at +1900 is another name to consider for Vegas. He is a secondary offensive driver behind Marner and provides the kind of versatile, high-impact play that resonates with Conn Smythe voters. If Vegas wins and Marner does not have a standout Final performance, Eichel becomes the alternative option.
Pavel Dorofeyev at +25,000 is a pure lottery ticket. He leads all Vegas skaters with 10 playoff goals and has quietly been one of the most productive wingers in the postseason. Vegas has done this before — Jonathan Marchessault won the 2023 Conn Smythe as a relative under-the-radar scorer. If Dorofeyev goes off in the Final, that line will look absurd.
The Case for Backing Andersen Now
If there is one bet to make in this market, it is Frederik Andersen at +250. The structure of Conn Smythe voting rewards the goaltender on the championship team more often than not, and Carolina is the favorite to win the series. His GAA of 1.44 is the kind of number that resonates with voters, and his narrative — a veteran goaltender finally getting his title run — adds the human element that awards voters often appreciate.
Marner is the safer bet if you are uncertain about the series winner. But for pure value, Andersen at +250 on the likely Cup champion is the stronger play. Books like DraftKings and FanDuel both have competitive lines on the Conn Smythe market heading into Game 1.
