Skip to content
News

Deshaun Watson in Concussion Protocol: Shedeur Sanders Eyes First Start as Browns Move to 3-Point Underdogs at Saints

Deshaun Watson is in the NFL's concussion protocol, putting Shedeur Sanders in line to start Sunday at New Orleans. Cleveland has moved from +2.5 to +3 against the Saints.

Proven Wagers
Wade Reeser

Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson has been placed in the NFL’s concussion protocol, and backup Shedeur Sanders is in line to make his first start of the season Sunday when the Browns visit the New Orleans Saints. The Browns announced the move Wednesday, and the betting market responded by moving Cleveland to a 3-point underdog.

Cleveland sits at 5-3 and is clinging to a spot in the AFC playoff picture after a 27-6 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 8. New Orleans is 2-5 and returns from its bye week, so a game that looked like a modest edge for the home side now carries real uncertainty at the sport’s most important position.

How Watson Ended Up in the Protocol

According to the team’s statement, Watson took a helmet-to-helmet hit in the first quarter of Sunday’s game at Pittsburgh. The ATC spotter called down to the sideline, and the Unaffiliated Neurotrauma Consultant administered a gameday concussion evaluation. Watson was cleared and returned on Cleveland’s next offensive series.

The Browns’ medical staff evaluated him again after the game and on Monday morning. Both times he showed no symptoms, passed his evaluations and was cleared. On Tuesday morning, however, Watson told the medical staff that he began experiencing concussion symptoms Monday night, and he was immediately placed in the protocol. The delayed onset explains why the announcement came days after the game.

The NFL’s protocol has five phases, running from symptom-limited activity through full football activity, and a player must also be cleared by an independent neurological consultant before returning. There is no official timetable, though NBC Sports and CBS Sports have reported a median recovery of about nine days. That puts Watson’s availability for Sunday in serious doubt, and his practice participation this week will be the key indicator.

The 31-year-old has been the Browns’ starter all season and has them at 5-3. He has completed 65.5 percent of his passes for 1,806 yards, seven touchdowns and three interceptions, and he has added 217 rushing yards and a score on 51 carries.

Shedeur Sanders Waits in the Wings

Sanders, a fifth-round pick in the 2025 draft, lost the starting job to Watson during the preseason and has played sparingly in 2026. He has appeared in two games, including a brief relief appearance against the Steelers in which he completed both of his pass attempts for two yards. As a rookie, he went 3-4 in seven starts while completing 56.6 percent of his passes for 1,400 yards, seven touchdowns and 10 interceptions.

The Browns carry four quarterbacks on their 53-man roster. Behind Watson and Sanders are Dillon Gabriel, a 2025 third-round pick who went 1-5 as a rookie starter and only recently returned from injured reserve with a back injury, and rookie Taylen Green, who has yet to take an NFL snap. Sanders is the clear next man up if Watson cannot clear the protocol.

Betting Market Reaction: Saints Favored, But Not By Much

Cleveland opened as a 2.5-point underdog at New Orleans, and the line has since moved to Browns +3 following the announcement. That half-point shift is small for a starting quarterback entering the protocol, which suggests oddsmakers either believe Watson still has a chance to play or see a limited gap between him and Sanders. Prices vary by book. One sportsbook listed the Saints at -2.5 (-110) with the Browns at +120 on the moneyline and a total of 43.5, while another had the Saints at -3 with moneylines of -148 and +124.

The key number to watch is 3. If Watson is ruled out, a move through the number toward Saints -3.5 would signal that the market assigns real value to the downgrade. If he practices and is listed as questionable, the line could drift back. Sanders’ limited playing time this season makes the Browns’ offensive output harder to project than usual, so the total of 43.5 is worth monitoring as well.

There are a few situational factors to weigh. Cleveland is 5-3 against the spread this season, while the Saints are 3-4 against the spread and 2-5 straight up. New Orleans is also 0-4 straight up at home, which is the main reason some analysts see value in Cleveland covering even if Watson does not play. The Saints have lost all eight games since the start of 2025 in which they committed two or more turnovers, and Sanders threw 10 interceptions in his seven starts last season, so ball security could decide the matchup.

On the prop market, expect Sanders’ passing yardage, completions and rushing lines to be posted once his status is confirmed. He has hit the longest rush over in each of his last five games, per BetMGM’s trend data, though that sample comes largely from limited snaps. If Watson is out, his own passing and rushing props will come off the board, and the Cleveland team total deserves a fresh look.

The Browns’ injury reports on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday will tell the story. Until Watson is cleared, treat every Cleveland number as provisional, and shop for the best line before the status is final. Kickoff from the Caesars Superdome is set for 1:00 p.m. ET on Sunday.

Subscribe for News updates

Join our newsletter to get the latest straight to your inbox!