Skip to content
MLB

Cardinals vs. Cubs Prediction: Clay Holmes and Wrigley Wind Favor Chicago Over St. Louis on Friday

The Cubs look to build on an 8-2 stretch against a Cardinals team riding its own hot streak, with Clay Holmes and a red-hot Alex Bregman set to headline Friday's series opener at Wrigley Field.

Earnest Horn
Earnest Horn

The Cubs have won 8 of their last 10 and still can’t shake the feeling that Milwaukee is playing a different sport, but Friday’s series opener against St. Louis is exactly the kind of get-right game a team on the fringe of a division race is supposed to win.

Quick take:

  • Pick: Chicago Cubs -1.5
  • Why: Clay Holmes and a top-five Cubs lineup against a Cardinals rotation piece who’s been homer-prone all season
  • The number to watch: Matthew Liberatore has allowed 20 home runs in 113.2 innings this year

Chicago sits second in the NL Central at 71-51, three games back of Milwaukee but comfortably ahead in the wild card chase, while St. Louis has quietly climbed back to 61-60 on the strength of a 7-3 stretch over its last ten. This isn’t a get-right game against a pushover — the Cardinals took two of three from the Phillies just this week — but Wrigley Field in mid-August with Clay Holmes on the mound is still a tough spot for a St. Louis club still 13 games out of first.

Wrigley Sets the Market Against a Struggling Lefty

Books have Chicago as a healthy -178 to -182 favorite on the moneyline, with St. Louis sitting around +160 to +164 as the road underdog. The run line has the Cubs at -1.5 (+116 to +125) and the Cardinals getting the extra run and a half at +1.5 (-140 to -150), while the total sits at 8 to 8.5 runs. That gap between moneyline and run-line pricing tells the real story: the market isn’t just picking a winner here, it’s pricing in a Cubs offense that’s capable of pulling away. Bettors shopping for the best number on this one can check a DraftKings promo code before locking in a side.

Holmes’ Command Versus Liberatore’s Long-Ball Problem

Clay Holmes takes the ball for Chicago sporting a 2.86 ERA and a tidy 1.16 WHIP, numbers that put him among the more reliable arms in a Cubs rotation that ranks middle of the pack as a group at 4.10. Across from him, Matthew Liberatore has scuffled to a 5-9 record and a 5.15 ERA, and the issue isn’t strikeouts — he’s fanned 110 in 113.2 innings — it’s the ball leaving the yard. Twenty home runs allowed is a rough number for a lefty working half his starts outside the wind-friendly comfort of Busch Stadium, and Wrigley in August, when the wind can blow out toward Waveland, is not the venue to fix that problem.

Chicago’s lineup gives him every reason to be careful. Pete Crow-Armstrong has been the engine, hitting .284 with 27 home runs, 73 RBI and 30 stolen bases, and just last week he mashed a 437-foot shot off the facade of the third deck against Washington. But it’s the supporting cast that’s rounded this offense into a genuine problem for opposing pitchers.

Alex Bregman hit his first career three-homer game on August 12, going deep as part of a 12-6 rout of the Nationals that pushed Chicago’s win streak to three.

Bregman’s overall line — .246 with 12 homers and 51 RBI in his first year in Chicago — isn’t eye-popping, but his recent surge (two homers in his last three games, five RBI in that span) shows a bat heating up at the right time. St. Louis counters with its own recent form: Alec Burleson is hitting .290 and Jordan Walker has been a steady presence in the middle of the order, and the Cardinals did just take two of three from a good Phillies club. This isn’t a Cardinals team rolling over. It’s a lineup capable of grinding out at-bats against a shaky Liberatore start, even on the road.

Prediction and Best Bet

Holmes gives Chicago length and limits the damage early, and with Liberatore’s home run rate working against him at Wrigley, the Cubs’ offense should find enough over six or seven innings to pull away late. St. Louis has the pitching depth in Kyle Leahy and Andre Pallante to keep this competitive on other days this series, but Friday’s matchup favors Chicago clearly enough to lean into the run line rather than just the moneyline.

Sat, Sep 12 • 7:16 PMSpreadMoneyTotal
Chicago White Sox
+1.5
(-210)
+100
O 8.5
(-104)
St. Louis Cardinals
+1.5
(-200)
-115
U 8.5
(-118)

The pick:

  1. Prediction: Cubs 6, Cardinals 3
  2. Best Bet: Cubs -1.5

Fade Liberatore’s home run issue in a hitter-friendly Wrigley wind and take Chicago to cover comfortably.

Subscribe for MLB updates

Join our newsletter to get the latest straight to your inbox!